Add extra d6 and discard the lowest die...

[1b2a]

Either you do the whole thing twice, or do everything once. And you don't roll two charge rolls, sp ots the latter. You roll one charge roll, add 2, remove 1

If you're combining abilites and can't follow the rules strictly, then you cant use both abilities, only choose one.

And since it's unclear, just do it how you think it works until it gets Faq'd. I will always roll 3d6 and remove one. Because when you do that You've satisfy the worded requirements in both abilites. If someone disagrees, well then just point out that a 3d6 charge is common. Bloodletters get 3d6 with a reroll for like 10 points. we sacrifice way more for getting this on a much weaker unit.

So since the rule is unclear, you can either play it the good way or the stupid way.

[bigbadbalou]

I think the correct answer would be ( 5+4=9", discard the 3 and the 1 ).

Although, I think you could theorically discard any 2 dice. So you could choose to discard the 5 and 4... But then again, why would you do that lol.

[hivefleetkerrigan]

I'm personally on the side of discard 3/1. If you failed your charge reroll them all and then discard the two lowest but am looking forward to a FAQ

[kazetanade]

The written rule says: "add a D6 to your charge. Remove 1 result."

If you did this twice you would be getting 4d6 remove 2 dice. So it's 5+4, discard 1 and 3.

[xenith]

You apply both abilities. As it is your turn, you choose the order in which they are applied. So you remove the mowest dice from one ability. Then you trigger the other ability which states to remove the lowest dice.

[bigbadbalou]

topaxygourouni already cleared the issue. It's not "remove lowest dice", it's "remove 1 dice". There really is no room for interpretation now. You add 2 dice before the roll, you remove 2 dice (any) after the roll.

If the rule would have been "remove the lowest", then it would be a different case and one could argue. But it's not, so...

[1b2a]

Dec 10, 2019 14:30:19 GMT bigbadbalou said:

topaxygourouni already cleared the issue. It's not "remove lowest dice", it's "remove 1 dice". There really is no room for interpretation now. You add 2 dice before the roll, you remove 2 dice (any) after the roll.

If the rule would have been "remove the lowest", then it would be a different case and one could argue. But it's not, so...

But if it says remove 1 die twice then you're removing 2 which breaks the rule lol VS adding a die which is irrespective of having added other dice for the other ability.

[No One]

You have a rule that says remove one die. So you remove a die. You have another rule that says you remove one die. So you remove a die. It's not hard, and is no different to 'add one dice'. It's not happening.

[dranzyl]

Yeah if we went with the remove one die not stucking interpretetion then neither would all those 'add one to the attack characteristic' rules.